Criminal Sexual ConductPress

Facial Recognition Technology Raises New Concerns About Wrongful Arrests

By October 28, 2026No Comments5 min read

Facial recognition technology has been linked to wrongful arrests across the U.S., including Detroit police’s 2020 arrest of Robert Williams, often when officers treated a software match as proof rather than a lead. Accuracy depends on image quality, lighting, camera angle, the algorithm used, and whether investigators independently verified the match.

–

As law enforcement agencies across the United States continue using facial recognition technology, criminal defense attorneys and civil liberties advocates are raising serious concerns about wrongful arrests, mistaken identity, and the reliability of AI-driven investigations.

A recent Associated Press report detailed the case of Porcha Woodruff, a Detroit woman who was wrongfully arrested after facial recognition technology was used during a carjacking investigation. Although her lawsuit was dismissed, the case renewed national attention on the risks of relying too heavily on technology-generated matches in criminal cases.

The issue has become part of a much larger debate over how artificial intelligence tools are being used in policing and whether enough safeguards exist to protect innocent people from being pulled into criminal investigations.

How Facial Recognition Technology Is Used In Criminal Investigations

Facial recognition technology compares an image from surveillance footage, social media, or another source against databases of existing images. Law enforcement may use the technology to generate potential leads during an investigation.

Supporters argue that facial recognition can help investigators identify suspects more quickly. Critics warn that the technology can pose serious risks when a possible match is treated as evidence rather than an investigative lead.

A Washington Post investigation found that some police departments relied on facial recognition matches despite warnings that the technology should not be used as the sole basis for an arrest.

Wrongful Arrest Cases Continue To Draw National Attention

One of the most widely cited examples involves Robert Williams, a Michigan man who was wrongfully arrested in 2020 after facial recognition technology incorrectly identified him as a suspect in a theft investigation.

Reuters reported on the case when civil liberties advocates filed a complaint with Detroit police, calling it the first known wrongful arrest in the United States linked to facial recognition technology.

The ACLU has since reported that more than a dozen people are now known to have been wrongfully arrested after police relied on facial recognition technology.

These cases raise serious questions about what happens when law enforcement places too much trust in technology before conducting a complete and independent investigation.

Why Accuracy And Verification Matter

Facial recognition technology can be affected by image quality, lighting, camera angle, database size, and other factors.

The National Institute of Standards and Technology has studied demographic effects in facial recognition systems and found that performance can vary depending on the algorithm and testing conditions.

Defense attorneys warn that once a person is identified by facial recognition software, investigators may begin interpreting other evidence through that initial assumption. That can create a dangerous risk of confirmation bias.

Shannon Smith On Facial Recognition And Due Process

“Facial recognition technology may be useful as an investigative tool, but it should never replace thorough police work,” said Shannon Smith, founder of Shannon Smith Law. “A computer-generated match is not the same thing as proof.”

“When someone is accused of a serious crime, every piece of evidence must be carefully examined,” Smith said. “That includes asking how the technology was used, whether the match was independently verified, and whether investigators relied too heavily on a result that may have been flawed.”

“Wrongful arrests can destroy reputations, careers, families, and futures,” Smith added. “As technology becomes more involved in criminal investigations, due process protections become even more important.”

Why Criminal Defense Attorneys Are Watching This Issue Closely

Facial recognition technology is likely to remain a major issue in criminal justice as law enforcement agencies continue adopting AI-driven tools.

For criminal defense attorneys, these cases highlight the importance of challenging questionable evidence, reviewing investigative methods, and ensuring that technology does not override constitutional protections.

At Shannon Smith Law, the defense team represents individuals facing allegations involving criminal sexual conduct, child abuse, and other serious felony charges throughout Michigan. In complex criminal cases, careful investigation and review of digital evidence can be critical.

Contact Shannon Smith Law

Shannon Smith is available to comment on facial recognition technology, wrongful arrests, digital evidence, due process concerns, and other high-profile criminal defense matters in Michigan and nationwide.

Shannon Smith Law represents clients throughout Michigan. To schedule a confidential consultation or for media inquiries, visit the firm’s contact page or call (248) 636-2595.